Executive Director of the Ghana Center for Democratic Development (CDD-Ghana) says the hurling of Dr Dominic Ayine before the disciplinary committee of the General Legal Council, over comments he made during an open dialogue, threatens the right to freedom of speech of every lawyer in the country.
According to Professor Henry Kwasi Prempeh, the act will also “impact negatively on both academic freedom and the freedom and ability of civil society to promote judicial accountability, including through projects like the Judicial Review series.”
Dr Ayine, a member of former President Mahama’s legal team during the 2020 Election petition, has questioned the judiciary's independence about how the Supreme Court arbitrated the Election Petition.
He was speaking at a Judicial review dialogue series last month on Presidential Election Petitions and their impact on Africa’s Democracy, organised by the Ghana Centre for Democratic Development (CDD Ghana) in collaboration with the Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology (KNUST) Law Faculty.
Dr Ayine maintained that the posture of the Supreme Court throughout the Election Petition hearing suggests that it had a “pre-determined agenda” to rule against the petitioner, John Dramani Mahama.
A similar statement during the hearing of the petition at a press briefing, February 16, 2021 resulted in his being found guilty of contempt of the Supreme Court, but was discharged after apologizing for his comments.
In the petition filed to the General Legal Council, the Judicial Secretary, Ms Cynthia Pamela Akotoaa Addo, stated that Dr Ayine’s alleged repeat of such statement has displeased the Chief Justice, thus the call for him to be investigated.
“His Lordship the Chief Justice, therefore, finds this alleged disparaging comments totally unacceptable and would like you to investigate this matter further,” the petition read.
However, reacting to this, Prof. Kwasi Prempeh asks, “So, now members of the Ghana Bar cannot offer a personal unflattering opinion of the judiciary on an academic, a civil society or other public discussion platforms, even after a case has been decided, without risking being hauled before the Disciplinary Committee of the General Legal Council?”
He stated that even though Dr. Ayine had made those comments, they were overwhelmingly disagreed with and shot down by other legal minds there, who had even praised the Court’s handling of the Petition.
“In other words, the platform on which the lawyer spoke was a veritable marketplace of ideas and opinion, with panelists debating each other in frank, open dialogue. It cannot be okay for a lawyer to praise a court but an act bordering on professional misconduct for another lawyer to express a contrary view of the court,” he said.
Prof. Kwasi Prempeh described the lodging of the complaint as “unprecedented, bizarre, and ill-advised” and could potentially curtail the freedom of speech right of lawyers to engage in projects like the Judicial Review Series to promote judicial accountability.
“I find no justification whatsoever for the Disciplinary Committee of the GLC to be brought into this matter or to investigate Dr. Dominic Akuritinga Ayine for the opinion he expressed on the panel,” he concluded.
Latest Stories
-
Boeing strike ends as workers accept new contract
32 mins -
GAF will not relent in its quest to counter external threats – GOC Southern Command
36 mins -
Election 2024: Bawumia reiterates commitment to promote sustainable mining practices
37 mins -
Ensign Global College promotes health and community well-being at Ngmayem Festival 2024
39 mins -
Bobrisky reveals reason for leaving Nigeria
1 hour -
Tiwa Savage discloses ‘craziest thing I’ve ever done for love’
1 hour -
US states worried about election unrest take security precautions
2 hours -
Modi condemns violence after Canada temple incident
2 hours -
Barcelona hit by new flood as rescuers search Valencia basement car park
2 hours -
Labadi Beach Hotel pays over GH¢16m as dividend to SSNIT
2 hours -
Elon Musk can keep giving $1m to voters, judge rules
2 hours -
Election must not divide us, government will protect each citizen – Akufo Addo
3 hours -
Novel way to beat dengue: Deaf mosquitoes stop having sex
3 hours -
Trial begins over beheading of teacher who showed Prophet Muhammed cartoon
3 hours -
‘See you soon’ – Bobrisky jets out of Nigeria
3 hours