The suddenly reluctant zipper can bring more than a sting of self-consciousness. A new study from the journal Plos One out this month found slight weight gain can hurt a job seeker’s employment chances — especially a woman’s.
The authors, a team of Scottish and Canadian researchers, already knew that overweight applicants face discrimination on the job hunt. They wondered if going up just one size could trigger similar prejudice.
In 2013, they told a group of 60 men and 60 women to imagine themselves as company recruiters looking at photos of prospective hires. The snapshots showed four men and four women, all white and expressionless, at various, digitally enhanced weights. Each face reflected what doctors consider healthy body weights. (For example, a 5-foot-7 woman who weighs between 121 and 158 pounds would not be medically considered obese.)
The authors said they wanted to test for response to size, so they stuck with one race:
The researchers told the group that the candidates had identical résumés. Then came the questionnaire: Based on your gut reactions, how likely would you be to hire each, on a scale of 1 (extremely unlikely) to 7 (extremely likely) for customer-facing roles or no-contact gigs?
A human resources manager might warn that deciding on the basis of a photo could invite a lawsuit. But the respondents made snap judgments. To faux recruiters of both genders, thinner faces registered as more hirable than the heavier ones, though the effect was stronger for roles that involved interaction with customers. The "original" versions pulled an average score of 4.84, while the modified, heavier mugs got 4.61.
The disadvantage, however, was stronger for larger women than for larger men. Respondents rated them 0.66 lower on average, compared to the 0.26 they docked the men.
“These results affirm that even a marginal increase in weight appears to have a negative impact on the hirability ratings of female job applicants,” the authors wrote. “For women, it seems, even seemingly minute changes to the shape, size and weight of the body are important.”
Co-author Dennis Nickson, a business professor at University of Strathclyde in Glasgow, said women tend to be judged more harshly for their appearances because of unfair societal expectations. Thin women who wear modest makeupappear more competent in the workplace and even take home higher earnings than their similarly skilled colleagues who weigh more or spurn cosmetics, studies have shown. (Other work has found that men, regardless of beauty, simply look more inherently skilled, and indeed the respondents in this study rated male faces, on average, a full point more employable than female ones.)
Latest Stories
-
No more miners trapped underground in South Africa, volunteers say
2 minutes -
US issues fresh round of sanctions against Russia ahead of Trump return to White House
18 minutes -
Death toll from South African mine siege rises to 78, rescued now at 166
31 minutes -
Biden takes aim at ‘tech industrial complex’ in farewell speech
41 minutes -
Biden says Gaza deal based on his framework while Trump claims credit
54 minutes -
The would-be African nation in love with Donald Trump
3 hours -
Ex-convict, 22, jailed in Tarkwa for threatening to stab student
3 hours -
JoyNews poll: Akufo-Addo, his government’s ‘killer’ taxes and nepotism blamed for NPP’s 2024 defeat
3 hours -
Malian PM arrives in Accra with special message for Mahama
4 hours -
Barca scores 5 again in Copa del Rey win over Betis
5 hours -
Harry Kane scores again as Bayern thrash Hoffenheim
5 hours -
Arsenal win North-London derby to close gap at the top
5 hours -
Djokovic breaks Federer record in Melbourne win
5 hours -
Foreign Affairs Ministry lists categories of recalled diplomatic and service passports
5 hours -
NAELP refutes defamatory claims, highlights achievements
6 hours