A research fellow at the University of Johannesburg (UJ), Dr. Edwin Coleman, says the argument that homosexuality is alien to African culture and values is factually incorrect.
According to him, academic texts, including anthropological studies into the precolonial era, have shown that although not legalised same sex relationships was tolerated in the African society.
Speaking on The Law on JoyNews, Dr Coleman explained that the texts showed that in some contexts it was for the purposes of war, farming, expression of the diverse nature of "Africanness" and humanity.
“We cannot restrict fundamental rights when what we are basing our restriction on is academically unsound and factually inaccurate...because historical facts allude to the fact that the African traditional society, promoted social inclusivity and that included same sex relationship.”
“In the context of Ghanaian law there is evidence that it did not explicitly promote same sex relationships, but what the Ghanaian customary law did not do is to ascribe a punishment in the form of criminality to it,” the researcher said.
Mr. Coleman told host, Joseph Ackah-Blay that the banning of unnatural carnal knowledge associated with LGBTQ+ practice and highlighting it in the constitution was only introduced during the colonial era.
“Let’s do some logical reasoning, why are you banning something if that thing did not exist? This is what I don’t get in this entire narrative, that it is alien to our values,” he added.
His comment comes after a private members bill aimed at fighting LGBTQ+ in the country was unveiled.
The Promotion of Proper Human Sexual Rights and Ghanaian Family Values Bill 2021 will see culprits face a jail term of up to ten years depending on the crime, if passed in its current state.
Individuals of the same sex who engage in sexual intercourse are “liable on summary conviction to a fine of not less than seven hundred and fifty penalty units and not more than five thousand penalty units, or to a term of imprisonment of not less than three years and not more than five years or both.”
This encompasses any person who “holds out as a lesbian, a gay, a transgender, a transsexual, a queer, a pansexual, an ally, a non-binary or any other sexual or gender identity that is contrary to the binary categories of male and female.”
The bill, according to Ningo Prampram MP, Samuel George, criminalises not just the activity but the promotion, advocacy and funding of the act.
Speaking at the Parliamentary Christian Fellowship meeting in June, Sam George said “we have established clearly that homosexuality is not a human rights, it is a lifestyle choice. So, we respect the human rights of practitioners of homosexuality to get a free and fair trial, however, their sexual orientation and choices cannot be deemed to be a human right and this is contained within the 1992 Constitution.”
However, Mr Coleman believes that the Ghanaian cultural values does not seek to promote hate unlike the bill.
According to him, all arguments raised to support the bill are not steeped in science and thus provide a weak base to stifle the basic human rights of a group of people.
The Researcher explained that “the state can intervene in fundamental human rights. No doubt about it.
“But my case is if we want to restrict human rights, if we want to restrict individual rights, we need to ensure that we have a justification that is properly grounded in science. I don’t see anything like that in this case, I don’t see anything like that in this one.”
Latest Stories
-
Police ‘waiting for court date’ on Erastus’ case is a lie – Samson Anyenini
7 mins -
Sports facilities are better managed by institutions – UG Sports Director on maintenance of Legon stadium
37 mins -
Ghanaian businesses must align vision with strategy to mitigate ESG Risks – KPMG
47 mins -
MTN achieves 30% localisation of Scancom PLC
48 mins -
Attorney-General: Some lawyers sacrifice ethics for ‘cheap’ political gains
60 mins -
Bond market: Volume up by 12.45% to GH¢746m
1 hour -
Cedi records year-to-date loss of nearly 29%; one dollar going for GH¢17.10
1 hour -
‘Our priorities are wrong in Ghana’ – UG Sports Director on sports development
1 hour -
The Fourth Estate’s investigative report wins 2nd place at 2024 AIJC
1 hour -
GPL: Our fans spur us on – GoldStars head coach Frimpong Manso on unbeaten run
2 hours -
Plantain chips are breaking hearts in Africa
2 hours -
61 new architects acquire state license to practice in Ghana
3 hours -
Masloc CEO honoured as capacity building Shero of the Year
3 hours -
MPs’ Repeated Attempts to Sue the Speaker: Unintended Consequences for the 2024 Elections?
3 hours -
Today’s front pages: Tuesday, November 5, 2024
3 hours