Former Ghana Ambassador to the Netherlands, Dr. Tony Aidoo, has expressed concern over the recent decisions made by the Supreme Court in cases involving political matters.
According to Dr. Aidoo, the apex court’s judgments have increasingly favored the ruling New Patriotic Party (NPP), a trend he believes raises questions about the court's neutrality.
Dr. Aidoo shared his views on JoyNews’ Newsfile, pointing out a pattern he perceives as an overreach by the Supreme Court, particularly in cases with political implications.
"The Supreme Court has, over the past years, especially under the Akufo-Addo administration, behaved in a manner as if it is a supranational, supraconstitutional body that can interfere in every act of Parliament,” he stated.
Dr. Aidoo described this trend as a deviation from the court’s mandate, suggesting it may be acting as “an extension of the New Patriotic Party.”
Dr. Aidoo cited the recent case brought by Majority Leader Alexander Afenyo-Markin, challenging the Speaker’s declaration of four parliamentary seats vacant.
He questioned the court’s basis for accepting the case, asserting that it did not present a legitimate cause for interpretation. “Afenyo-Markin’s writ did not show any legal cause for interpretation,” he argued.
"All it showed was the consequences of the act of the four Members of Parliament, that they will be deprived of their membership and so on. Those are not legal matters. They are the consequences of their actions under a constitutional provision that is clear and does not require interpretation.”
According to Dr. Aidoo, the court’s willingness to address matters that lack a legal basis for interpretation is indicative of judicial overreach, especially in cases where constitutional provisions are unambiguous.
He expressed his concern that such decisions may undermine the court’s credibility and weaken public confidence in the judiciary’s independence.
"What happened to the constituents in Assin North regarding Gyakye Quayson's case? Weren’t they also deprived of representation? Where about SALL? The thousands of people in SALL who have been denied representation for four years. The Supreme Court is not predictable in its application of the law. And I said that does not help our democratic process. Today, you stand here, you contradict yourself. Tomorrow, you stand there, contradict yourself. Did we set up a support supra-constitutional body to terrorize us or to guide our constitutional behavior," he said.
On October 30, the Supreme Court dismissed an application by Speaker of Parliament Alban Bagbin, who sought to overturn the Court’s ruling that suspended his declaration of four parliamentary seats as vacant.
This follows an initial suit filed by Effutu MP Alexander Afenyo-Markin, challenging the Speaker's declaration.
The Speaker's legal team argued that the Supreme Court lacked jurisdiction in this case, among other grounds canvassed in court.
However, after hearing arguments from all parties, including the Attorney-General and Minister for Justice, the Supreme Court maintained that its earlier ruling was appropriate, stating that the Speaker’s appeal was without merit.
"We have considered the application, and we have come to the conclusion that the grounds supporting the application have no merit," the Chief Justice stated.
Prior to this decision, the Court also dismissed an objection raised by Thaddeus Sory, counsel for the Speaker, regarding the empaneling of Justice Ernest Gaewu.
Latest Stories
-
I’m proud that despite all the challenges, we have maintained Free SHS – Akufo Addo
11 mins -
Alan’s running mate, KOD says GRASP will revolutionize care for the Elderly in rural areas
13 mins -
Election 2024: Alan paints Accra yellow as the crowd marches through the capital with him
28 mins -
Vacant seats: Speaker has not done what would have led to greater peace – Kofi Bentil
38 mins -
Police on manhunt for Adabraka daylight robbers
39 mins -
Lordina Mahama presents medical supplies and equipment to Tishigu Health Center
54 mins -
Lordina Mahama urges Ghanaians to prioritise regular health screenings
55 mins -
EC to reassess decision on presidential ballot printing next week – Dr Bossman Asare
1 hour -
Shark attacks surfer, 61, on Hawaiian island of Maui
1 hour -
29 Nigerian children may be sentenced to death for protesting against cost-of-living crisis
1 hour -
Nigerian becomes first black woman to lead major political party in the UK
2 hours -
Perception issues affecting Supreme Court – Nii Armah Addy
2 hours -
Armed men bolt with cash at Adabraka market in dramatic daylight robbery
2 hours -
Bawku Conflict: National Security fully aware of events – Bawku Naaba’s lawyer
2 hours -
Dodome to celebrate festival in a bid to construct traditional council facility
3 hours